Comparison
All three are supplemental cash-benefit policies, but they pay for different events. Here's how they differ and how each fits with Medicare Advantage or Medigap.
or call Matt: 704-802-2523 · text 704-237-0754
Free, no obligation

This is a limited benefit hospital indemnity policy. It is supplemental insurance, not major medical coverage, and does not replace comprehensive health insurance. Benefits are fixed dollar amounts for covered inpatient stays and may include waiting periods, pre-existing condition limitations and exclusions. See the policy for full details.
Important: Hospital indemnity is a limited-benefit supplemental policy. It is not major medical insurance and does not replace health insurance or Medicare. Benefits, limitations, exclusions and availability vary by carrier and state.
| Hospital indemnity | Critical illness | Cancer | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What triggers a benefit | A covered hospital admission or stay (plus optional benefits) | Diagnosis of a covered condition, often heart attack, stroke, cancer and others listed in the policy | Diagnosis of covered cancer, plus treatment benefits on some plans |
| How it typically pays | Fixed amount per day or per admission | Usually a lump sum | Lump sum and/or scheduled treatment benefits |
| Best matches | Inpatient copays and deductibles | Big one-time costs and lost income after a serious diagnosis | Costs of cancer treatment, travel and lost income |
| Fit with Medicare Advantage | Strong: can offset daily inpatient copays | Can help with costs up to your out-of-pocket max and non-medical costs | Can help with chemo/radiation coinsurance and non-medical costs |
| Fit with Medigap | Weaker for copays (Medigap may cover much of them); useful for non-medical cash | Cash for non-medical costs | Cash for non-medical costs |
Exact covered conditions, amounts, waiting periods and exclusions vary by carrier and state.
More detail: critical illness insurance.
Not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program.
Yes. They're separate policies that pay for different events, and each pays according to its own terms.
Hospital indemnity lines up most directly with MA's daily inpatient copays. Critical illness and cancer plans can help with other costs after a serious diagnosis.
Email: matt@themacmillanagency.com
Important: Hospital indemnity insurance pays fixed-dollar cash benefits for covered inpatient stays. It does not replace comprehensive medical coverage or guarantee payment in full of all hospital charges. This is a solicitation for insurance. By responding you will be contacted by a licensed insurance agent. The MacMillan Agency is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. government, the federal Medicare program, or any state agency. Hospital indemnity insurance is supplemental coverage and is not a substitute for major medical coverage, and it does not satisfy the requirement for minimum essential coverage. Plans, benefits, limitations, exclusions and availability vary by state and carrier. Benefit amounts depend on the plan selected. Licensed in AL, AZ, DE, DC, FL, GA, IL, IN, LA, MD, MI, NJ, NC, OH, PA, SC, TN, TX, UT, VA, WA.